How could C.Martinerie and M.Laurent ignore B. Perbal scientific leadership and forget that they were in B.Perbal's group and under his direction when these experiments were performed ?

How could C.Martinerie, M.Laurent and Y.Le bouc have forgotten that Pr Kyurkchiev came especially to the St Antoine Hospital, upon the invitation of B. Perbal, to purify the K19M antibody which was used in this work ?

How could C. Gicquel have forgotten the leadership and participation of B. Perbal when she was sending herself to B. Perbal for interpretation and inclusion in the upcoming draft, the informations regarding the patients tested in this work ?

How could Y.Le Bouc accept that the name of B. Perbal be withdrawn and sign as the senior author, a manuscript reporting expression of a gene for which he had no previous expertise ?